Best Eyeliner in India: 5 Liquid and Gel Picks by Need


reviewguide.in logo

Updated:

Published:


Open makeup brush roll with brushes in front of a mirror with round vanity lights, a typical make up station for an eyeliner routine

Open makeup brush roll with brushes in front of a mirror with round vanity lights, a make up station for an eyeliner routine
Photo by Reynaldo Yodia on Pexels

The best eyeliner in India is the one that does what you want: dry quickly, stay where you draw it and come off cleanly at night. That is hard to judge from a listing, because liquid, gel and fine-tip liners come with different applicators.

We compared Amazon.in listings for popular liners and kept five picks for different needs and habits. Every pick links to its Amazon.in listing, and the comparison table lines them up.

Read the eye-safety advice before you choose. The US FDA says misusing eye cosmetics can let dangerous bacteria or fungi grow in them, and it says never to share them. The American Academy of Ophthalmology (AAO) says to throw away eye makeup after three months. We call no pick safe.

Start with the comparison table, then read who should buy and who should skip each pick. The guide that follows covers eye safety, liquid versus gel, how to apply and remove eyeliner, and where to buy.

Quick answer: Our top pick is the Maybelline New York Colossal Bold Eyeliner, for readers who want an everyday black liquid liner. Choose by format and applicator from the list below.

  • Best overall: Maybelline New York Colossal Bold Eyeliner
  • Best glass-bottle liner: Lakmé Ultimate Glam Eye Liner
  • Best gel eyeliner: Maybelline New York Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner
  • Best flexi-tip liquid eyeliner: Lakmé Eyeconic Liquid Eyeliner
  • Best fine-tip liquid eyeliner: FACESCANADA Magneteyes Eyeliner

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

QUICK SUMMARY: Top 5 Best Eyeliner in India

  1. Maybelline New York Colossal Bold Eyeliner
  2. Lakmé Ultimate Glam Eye Liner
  3. Maybelline New York Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner
  4. Lakmé Eyeconic Liquid Eyeliner
  5. FACESCANADA Magneteyes Eyeliner
Maybelline New York Colossal Bold Eyeliner in black, a liquid eyeliner bottle with a long handle, listed as smudge proof and waterproof

1. Maybelline New York Colossal Bold Eyeliner

Features

  • Liquid eyeliner in a bottle, with a brush tip and a long handle
  • Listed as smudge proof and waterproof, with a 24 hour wear claim
  • Matte finish in black
  • The maker’s safety line says it is for external use only
  • Ingredient list names hydrogenated palm kernel glycerides, carnauba wax and mica, among others
  • Country of origin listed as India
  • 4.3 stars and 39,000+ ratings on Amazon.in

Lakme Ultimate Glam Eye Liner in black, a glass bottle with a screw cap and brush applicator, listed as semi matte and water resistant

2. Lakmé Ultimate Glam Eye Liner

Features

  • Liquid eyeliner in a glass bottle with a screw cap and a brush
  • Listed as semi matte and water resistant
  • Net quantity listed as 9 ml
  • Ingredient line on the listing names only aqua, triethanolamine and xanthan gum, so check the full list on the pack
  • Made in India by Hindustan Unilever, with maker details on the listing
  • 4.1 stars and 41,000+ ratings on Amazon.in

Maybelline New York Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner in Blackest Black, a gel liner jar with a pack beside it, listed as smudge proof and waterproof

3. Maybelline New York Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner

Features

  • Gel eyeliner in a jar, applied with a liner brush
  • Listed as smudge-proof and waterproof, with a 36 hour wear claim
  • Maker describes the formula as oil-free
  • Intense black colour, with the finish listed as glossy
  • Ingredient list names cyclopentasiloxane, ceresin and candelilla wax, among others
  • The maker’s safety line says to keep it in a cool, dry place
  • 4.2 stars and 19,000+ ratings on Amazon.in

Lakme Eyeconic Liquid Eyeliner with an ergonomic cap and flexi-tip applicator beside its pack, listed as quick drying, smudge proof and waterproof

4. Lakmé Eyeconic Liquid Eyeliner

Features

  • Liquid eyeliner with a flexi-tip applicator and an ergonomic cap
  • Listed as quick-drying in about 15 seconds, smudge-proof and waterproof, with a 24 hour wear claim
  • Matte finish
  • Ingredient list names aqua, acrylates/ethylhexyl, silica, glycerine and caprylyl glycol
  • The maker’s safety line says to rinse with clean water if it touches the eyes and to stop use if irritation persists
  • Made in India by Hindustan Unilever, with maker details on the listing
  • 4.2 stars and 12,000+ ratings on Amazon.in

FACESCANADA Magneteyes Eyeliner in black, a liquid eyeliner bottle with a fine tip applicator, listed as quick drying, waterproof and smudgeproof

5. FACESCANADA Magneteyes Eyeliner

Features

  • Liquid eyeliner in a bottle, with a fine tip applicator
  • Listed as quick-drying, waterproof and smudgeproof, with a 24 hour wear claim
  • Maker says it is enriched with almond oil
  • The ingredient line on the listing names almond oil extract only, so check the pack
  • Matte finish in black
  • Country of origin listed as India
  • 4.1 stars and 10,000+ ratings on Amazon.in

Comparison at a Glance

This table lines up the five picks by format, wear claim, named ingredients and star average. Use it to shortlist two, then read the verdicts below.

PickBest forType on the listingWear time claimedIngredients named on the listingStars on Amazon.inWhere to buy
Maybelline New York Colossal Bold EyelinerBest overallLiquid, brush tipUp to 24 hoursHydrogenated palm kernel glycerides, carnauba wax, mica4.3Check price on Amazon
Lakmé Ultimate Glam Eye LinerGlass-bottle linerLiquid, brush in a glass bottleNot stated on the listingAqua, triethanolamine, xanthan gum4.1Check price on Amazon
Maybelline New York Lasting Drama Gel EyelinerGel eyelinerGel in a jar, applied with a brushUp to 36 hoursCyclopentasiloxane, ceresin, candelilla wax4.2Check price on Amazon
Lakmé Eyeconic Liquid EyelinerFlexi-tip liquidLiquid, flexi-tipUp to 24 hoursAqua, acrylates/ethylhexyl, silica4.2Check price on Amazon
FACESCANADA Magneteyes EyelinerFine-tip liquidLiquid, fine tipUp to 24 hoursAlmond oil extract4.1Check price on Amazon

How We Chose the Best Eyeliner in India

We compared Amazon.in listings for popular liners, reading the titles, bullets, product details and ingredient lists, then kept one pick for each format or applicator. We weighed star averages and rating counts. We also read the FDA and AAO advice, linked in this guide.

We left out kajal pencils, eyebrow pencils and eyeshadow, because they need different advice. Every wear-time claim in this guide is the maker’s own.

Who Should Buy Which Pick (and Who Should Skip It)

Each verdict sets one pick against another from the list, then names the buyer it suits and the buyer who should look elsewhere.

1. Maybelline Colossal Bold: best overall

Beats the Lakmé Ultimate Glam on star average, though that pick has the bigger buyer pool.

  • Buy it if you are buying your first liquid eyeliner.
  • Skip it if you want the longest wear claim on this list: get the Maybelline Lasting Drama Gel.

2. Lakmé Ultimate Glam: best glass-bottle liner

Has a bigger buyer pool than the Maybelline Lasting Drama Gel, with a lower star average.

  • Buy it if you wear eyeliner on most days of the week.
  • Skip it if you want the maker to state how long it lasts before you buy: get the Maybelline Colossal Bold.

3. Maybelline Lasting Drama Gel: best gel eyeliner

Has fewer ratings than the Maybelline Colossal Bold, and a lower star average.

  • Buy it if you are building a fuller makeup kit for evenings out.
  • Skip it if you want the maker’s advice on what to do if it gets in your eyes: get the Lakmé Eyeconic Liquid.

4. Lakmé Eyeconic Liquid: best flexi-tip liquid eyeliner

Trails the Maybelline Colossal Bold on star average and on buyer pool.

  • Buy it if you are buying a gift for someone who already wears eye makeup.
  • Skip it if you want a glossy finish: get the Maybelline Lasting Drama Gel.

5. FACESCANADA Magneteyes: best fine-tip liquid eyeliner

Has the smallest buyer pool of the five and a lower star average than the Lakmé Eyeconic Liquid.

  • Buy it if you want a second liner to keep in your work bag.
  • Skip it if your eyes react easily to new products: read the sensitive-eyes advice in this guide first.

Is Eyeliner Safe for Your Eyes?

No listing can prove that an eyeliner is safe, so treat eye safety as a set of habits, not a label claim. The FDA and the AAO give plain rules for all eye makeup. We do not claim that either body endorses a pick here.

What the FDA Says About Eye Cosmetics

The FDA says most eye cosmetics are safe when used properly. It also says misusing them can allow dangerous bacteria or fungi to grow, and that an infection can follow. In rare cases, it says, women have been temporarily or permanently blinded by an infection from an eye cosmetic.

  • Irritation: stop using any eye cosmetic that irritates your eyes, and see a doctor if it persists.
  • Hands and tools: wash your hands before you apply, and make sure any instrument near your eyes is clean.
  • No sharing: never share or swap eye cosmetics, and use single-use applicators if you sample one in a shop.
  • Right product: use only products meant for the eyes: the FDA says not to use a lip liner as an eyeliner.
  • Moving vehicles: never apply or remove eye cosmetics in a moving vehicle.
  • Infection: avoid eye cosmetics during an eye infection, and discard the ones you were using when it started.

What the AAO Says About Eye Makeup

The AAO gives plain rules that apply to any eyeliner, whatever the brand or format. Follow them whichever pick you choose.

  • Made for the eyes: use only cosmetics that are designed for use around the eyes.
  • Replace: eye makeup goes in the bin after three months, and you buy new.
  • Creamy and liquid products: infection-causing bacteria grow easily in them.
  • Never share: do not share eye makeup, even with family or close friends.
  • Placement: apply it outside the lash line, away from the eye.
  • Night: remove all eye makeup before sleeping.
Flat lay of eye makeup brushes, eye pads and a pot of lip colour on a black slate tray, set out for an eye makeup routine
Photo by Nataliya Vaitkevich on Pexels

Sensitive Eyes, Allergies and Contact Lenses

Introduce only one new eye makeup product at a time, especially if you tend to react easily, as the AAO advises. Wait until you know you are not reacting before you add another. If you do react, find out the ingredients so you can watch for them in other products, and tell your doctor.

The AAO also names glitter eye makeup as a common cause of corneal irritation or infection, especially for people who wear contact lenses. If that is you, skip sparkle liners and ask your eye doctor about your routine.

Kohl and Kajal Labels

The FDA warns against true kohl, which it says consists of salts of heavy metals such as antimony and lead, and says to keep it away from children. It adds that some eye cosmetics carry the word kohl only to name a shade. Our best kajal in India guide covers that warning in full.

How to Choose the Best Eyeliner for Your Eyes

Choose by format, applicator tip, the maker’s wear claim, and how the liner comes off. Check these points on the listing before you add a liner to your basket.

Liquid Eyeliner vs Gel Eyeliner: Which Should You Buy?

Choose the format whose applicator you can control best. The liquid picks here have a brush or tip built into the pack. The gel pick here sits in a jar, and you load a brush from it. The format alone does not tell you how long it lasts or how well it suits your eyes.

  • Liquid picks here: the applicator is built into the pack, so there is no separate brush to lose.
  • Gel pick here: a separate brush that you load yourself and must keep clean.
  • Either way: follow the maker’s directions and keep the pack closed between uses.

Brush, Flexi and Fine Tips: Which Applicator Suits You?

Brush, flexi and fine tips feel different in the hand, so pick the tip you find easiest to steady. Choose the type you are most comfortable holding, and keep the drawing hand steady by resting your elbow on a table.

Woman applying makeup with a compact mirror surrounded by beauty products, a typical at-home eyeliner routine
Photo by Trần Long on Pexels

Waterproof Eyeliner and Smudge Proof Eyeliner Claims

Listings use waterproof, water resistant and smudge proof as separate claims, and each is the maker’s own. A waterproof eyeliner is judged by what buyers report, so read reviews from people in a climate like yours. Check the pack for how the maker says to remove it.

Long Lasting Eyeliner: How to Read Wear-Time Claims

Wear-time claims given in hours are the maker’s own. For a long lasting eyeliner, read the three-star reviews for complaints about fading or smudging, and weigh the claim against them.

Ingredients and Pack Details

Read the ingredient list on the pack, not only on the listing, because a listing can be incomplete. Check that the maker’s name, batch details and any best use before date are printed. Avoid any ingredient that you know irritates your eyes.

Should You Apply Eyeliner on the Waterline?

Keep eyeliner off the inner rim of the eye. The AAO advises applying eye makeup outside the lash line, away from the eye, so that the oil glands of the upper or lower eyelid stay unblocked. If you have an eye condition, ask your doctor, as the AAO advises.

The AAO explains that these glands secrete oil that protects the surface of the eye. That is why the advice is to keep makeup away from the eye itself.

How to Apply Eyeliner Step by Step

Start with clean hands, a clean face and clean eyelids, then draw a thin line along the base of the upper lashes. Build the line in short strokes, and keep the tip away from the eye itself.

  • Prepare: the AAO says to make sure your face and eyelids are very clean before you apply makeup.
  • Draw: start at the inner corner and draw along the upper lash line, then extend the stroke slightly past the outer corner for a wing.
  • Let it set: follow the directions on the pack for drying time before you blink.
  • Close it: cap the bottle or jar after each use, and keep the tip clean.
  • Moving vehicles: the AAO says never to apply makeup in a moving vehicle.
Woman with curly hair removing her makeup with a cotton pad in a bedroom, the nightly step after wearing eyeliner
Photo by Kaboompics on Pexels

How to Remove Eyeliner at Night

Remove all eye makeup before you sleep. The AAO says eye makeup that is not removed properly can cause irritation. Use an eye makeup remover on a soft pad and wipe gently, then rinse the remover off your eyelids and avoid getting it in your eyes.

  • Remover: use an eye makeup remover, and check the pack for the maker’s removal advice.
  • Soft pad: press a soft cotton pad on the lid and wipe, instead of rubbing hard. See our best cotton pads for makeup removal guide.
  • Remnants: the AAO says to brush a clean cotton swab along the base of the lashes to remove what is left.
  • Cleanse: wash your face after removal. Our best face wash in India guide can help you choose one.

When Should You Replace Your Eyeliner?

Replace it about every three months, which is the AAO’s advice for eye makeup. Replace it sooner after an eye infection, because the AAO says to toss all eye makeup then. Do not keep a bottle or jar because it still has product left.

  • Date: note the month you open the pack, and any best use before date printed on it.
  • Hygiene: keep the cap on, and do not lend the liner to anyone.
  • Heat: the FDA says heat can weaken the preservative, so do not leave cosmetics in a hot car.
  • Irritation: if your eyes sting or the area looks inflamed, stop using it, as the FDA advises.

Eyeliner vs Kajal: What Is the Difference?

Eyeliner and kajal are sold as separate products, so read the listing to see which one a pack is sold as. This guide covers liquid and gel eyeliners. For pencil-style kohl products, read our best kajal in India guide.

  • What the maker sells: the title and bullets say whether a product is sold as eyeliner, as kajal or as both.
  • The look you want: check the product photos and the reviews for the finish you want.

Where to Buy Eyeliner in India

Buy from the brand’s own store or a named seller, whether on Amazon.in or in a shop. Check the seal and any batch details when it arrives, and read the return policy before you open the pack.

  • Listing: look for pack photos, an ingredient list and maker details.
  • Seller: prefer the brand’s own store page or a clearly named seller.
  • On arrival: check the seal and the batch details on the pack.
  • Returns: read the return window before you use the product.

How to Read Buyer Reviews

For a smudge proof eyeliner, look for reviews from buyers whose eyes and climate are like yours. Star averages show the overall mood, and the written reviews show the details that matter to you.

  • Wear: for a long lasting eyeliner, look for reviewers who describe a full day outdoors or in the heat.
  • Rating mix: compare the star average with the number of ratings behind it.
  • Eye comfort: a review that mentions stinging or watering is one buyer’s experience. If your own eyes sting or water after you use any eye makeup, stop using it and tell your doctor.

Final Thoughts: Picking the Best Eyeliner in India

Our overall pick is the Maybelline New York Colossal Bold Eyeliner.

If your need is more specific, choose by use case:

Frequently Asked Questions

Which eyeliner is better, gel or liquid?

Neither format wins for everyone, so choose the applicator you can control. The liquid picks here have a built-in applicator, while the gel pick comes in a pot that you load with a brush. Judge any liner by the maker’s directions and by buyer reviews, not by format alone, and see our comparison table.

Is gel eyeliner good for eyes?

No listing can show that a gel eyeliner is good for your eyes. The FDA says misuse can let bacteria grow in eye cosmetics, and the AAO says to use only cosmetics designed for use around the eyes. Keep the jar clean, never share it, and stop using any eyeliner that irritates your eyes.

Which eyeliner is best, Lakmé or Maybelline?

Neither brand wins on its name, and both appear in our picks. Compare the exact liner, not the brand: the format, the applicator, the maker’s wear claim and the buyer ratings. Our table lines up two Lakmé and two Maybelline picks, so you can compare them side by side.

What is the best eyeliner that stays on all day?

Pick a waterproof eyeliner or a smudge proof eyeliner whose listing claims long wear, then check buyer reviews for how it held up in a climate like yours. Wear times given in hours are the maker’s own claims. A waterproof eyeliner may need a proper eye makeup remover at night.

How often should I replace my eyeliner?

Replace it after three months, as the AAO advises for eye makeup. The AAO also says infection-causing bacteria grow easily in creamy or liquid eye makeup. Replace it at once after an eye infection such as pink eye, when the AAO says to toss all of your eye makeup.

Can I use a lip liner as an eyeliner?

No. The FDA says not to use cosmetics near your eyes unless they are intended for that use, and it gives a lip liner as its example, because of contamination from the mouth and colour additives not approved for the eye area. Choose a product sold for use on the eyes, and check that the pack names the eyes as the intended use.

How do I remove waterproof eyeliner?

Use an eye makeup remover and a soft cotton pad, and wipe gently instead of rubbing. The AAO says to remove all eye makeup before sleeping, because leftover makeup can cause irritation. Avoid getting remover in your eyes and rinse it off your eyelids. Check the pack for the maker’s removal advice.

Related reads:

Share on:

Category:

About The Author

reviewguide.in logo

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *